Carbon-based approaches for saving rainforests should include biodiversity studies
New study finds that a universal relationship between biodiversity, carbon storage in tropical forests may not exist as once assumed
Date : March 10, 2017
Source : Wildlife Conservation Society
Summary: Conservationists working to safeguard tropical
forests often assume that old growth forests containing great stores of carbon
also hold high biodiversity, but a new study finds that the relationship may
not be as strong as once thought, according to a group of researchers.
A rainforest
in Gabon. Conservationists working to safeguard tropical forests often assume
that old growth forests containing great stores of carbon also hold high
biodiversity, but a new study finds that the relationship may not be as strong
as once thought.
Credit:
Miguel Leal
Conservationists working to safeguard
tropical forests often assume that old growth forests containing great stores
of carbon also hold high biodiversity, but a new study finds that the
relationship may not be as strong as once thought, according to a group of
researchers with contributions from WCS (Wildlife Conservation Society) and
other organizations.
Tropical forests are exceptionally rich in both
carbon and biodiversity, but the study recently published in the journal Scientific
Reports indicates that, within the tropics, tree diversity and forest
carbon do not necessarily correlate, and that there is no detectable
relationship between the two factors across a region, a scale relevant for
conservation planning and the establishment of protected areas. For instance,
in Central Africa, some areas that are dominated by one or a few tree species
are high in carbon density, whereas some forests with many more tree species
have a lower carbon density.
The study titled "Diversity and carbon
storage across the tropical forest biome" can be accessed here.
"The findings of the study show that there
is not always a win-win situation whereby, when you conserve high-carbon forest
stocks, you also automatically conserve high tree diversity," said Miguel
Leal, WCS scientist and a co-author on the study. "Forest carbon density
maps are increasingly easy to create from remote-sensing data. If the high
carbon density and high species diversity were invariably in the same places,
we could easily pinpoint the areas important for conservation. That would make
our work more efficient and save scarce resources, because biodiversity
assessments are expensive and time consuming,"
Leal added: "As a conservation NGO, WCS
wants to ensure that biodiversity is given due consideration in efforts to
mitigate climate change. This study demonstrates that it is not safe to assume
that, by simply protecting high-carbon forests, we are protecting all the areas
with high levels of biodiversity."
Most of the countries with large tracts of tropical
forests are pursuing the REDD+ (Reduced Emissions from Deforestation and forest
Degradation) program under the UNFCCC to safeguard areas with large carbon
stocks. Previous studies found that, at a local scale, higher carbon also
implied higher tree species richness. However, this larger, more comprehensive
study shows that this is not the case over most tropical areas.
The scientists compared data from 360 plots in
old-growth rainforests in Latin America, Africa, and Asia to examine the
relationship between tropical tree diversity and the amount of carbon stocks
contained above ground in those same plots. The results of the study revealed a
weak relationship between tree diversity and above ground carbon stocks in
Asia, and no statistical connection between the two factors in Africa and Latin
America. The team did find a weak positive relationship between tree diversity
and carbon stocks at scales much smaller than a hectare.
The research team asserted that the absence of a
clear relationship between tree diversity and carbon storage meant that using
carbon-centered metrics alone to guide conservation planning may be missing
many ecosystems with high biodiversity. For the future, the authors recommend
that effective tropical forest conservation requires that an explicit
distinction be made between tree diversity and carbon stocks, and that both be
considered in parallel.
The authors added that only in places where the
relationship between high tree diversity and carbon levels has been established
can one be used as an indicator for the other. Specifically, the plots examined
in Southeast Asia were found to be both diverse in tree species and carbon
biomass, a finding that underlines the need to protect such forests.
Wildlife Conservation Society.
"Carbon-based approaches for saving rainforests should include
biodiversity studies: New study finds that a universal relationship between
biodiversity, carbon storage in tropical forests may not exist as once
assumed." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 10 March 2017.
<www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/03/170310132634.htm>
Komentar
Posting Komentar